Carrying Weapons
- Andrew Greyscar

- New Member

- G'day Mates
- Posts: 8
- Thank Yous: 6
8 years 2 months ago #151018
by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis)
Andrew Greyscar (Master Florentine Swashbuckler)
Oliver Greenbottle (Alchemist)
OOG: Michael Tollis
Carrying Weapons was created by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis)
My character is a dual wielder (master florentine, dual 1HE) and I was curious as to what the best way is to carry 2 full size weapons.
A sword frog on either side? 1 double frog on one side? dual back harness?
Is there an easy way to carry several weapons without purchasing sword frogs?
Thanks.
A sword frog on either side? 1 double frog on one side? dual back harness?
Is there an easy way to carry several weapons without purchasing sword frogs?
Thanks.
Andrew Greyscar (Master Florentine Swashbuckler)
Oliver Greenbottle (Alchemist)
OOG: Michael Tollis
- Matt D

- Platinum Member

- Photographer extraordinaire!
- Posts: 1998
- Thank Yous: 557
8 years 2 months ago #151019
by Matt D (MattD)
Elias Ashby
Proprietor of the Ashby Family General Store
Lord Templar Rayven Nightwing of the Order of Holy Light
(OOG - Matt D. - Photographer)
Replied by Matt D (MattD) on topic Carrying Weapons
I've actually done every method you describe. And when in lazy, just carry them by the blade together. The most comfortable way I find is two frogs. Though if you cannot do that, you can get a long strip of cloth to fashion a belt out of it. Never put your weapons in a leather belt, because ut will damage the weapon
Elias Ashby
Proprietor of the Ashby Family General Store
Lord Templar Rayven Nightwing of the Order of Holy Light
(OOG - Matt D. - Photographer)
The following user(s) said Thank You: Mantel (sigma-j), Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis)
- Grumpy

- Junior Member

- May be appeased with kittens.
- Posts: 90
- Thank Yous: 64
8 years 2 months ago #151044
by Grumpy (Bookwyrm)
Main: Grigori the grumpy healer, adopted member of the Tribe of Berk, adviser to Chief Darius Redmaw.
Alt: Dorian White, physician and alchemist for hire.
Alt: Ruy Sanchez de Castor y Ortiz, the best swordsman in all of Coast Haven!
OOC: Matthew Bowman
Science fiction and fantasy editor, longtime tabletop GM, newbie KR player.
Replied by Grumpy (Bookwyrm) on topic Carrying Weapons
You can get "mug frogs" from various sites for four bucks that snap closed, which work very well as cheap frogs. However, for most weapons you will have to snap it open in order to draw, which isn't so good for florentine use.
I find the best way is to have two swords on opposite hips from the hands that will be holding them. Back sheaths look cool but are impractical both coming and going. Same-side sheathes tend to only work when you have a much shorter secondary weapon. (Remember, unlike in real life, you do have to be concerned about latex and foam catching on the sides of the frog. Steel is a different matter.)
Another thing to be concerned about is that the combination of length of blade and angle of frog might cause inconvenience. I have three types of frogs (other than the mug frog, which is only used for a mug). One is a high, fixed frog which keeps my sword off the ground but doesn't allow much flexibility when sitting. The second is lower and more flexible, but if I'm not careful can let the tip of my sword drag on the ground; I've even (once) managed to trip on my own sword because it swung between my legs while I was walking fast. Both of these are angled at about 40 degrees or so. The third frog is straight up and down, and typically gives me the least problems, but I also use that frog to carry my offhand weapon; while it's a 1HE, it's shorter and skinnier.
When shopping for frogs, keep in mind that you'll want to be able to draw in a hurry; sometimes fights get sprung on you completely out of the blue, and it's not fair to the NPCs (not to mention immersion-breaking) to ask them to wait while you get situated for anything less than a safety concern, even if they want to. (And they aren't required to, again excepting safety. Safety means something like "I'm carrying this heavy/breakable object. Please hold a moment while I move it off to the side, then return to my spot where you can proceed to kill me." I did that with a drink this last event. It can also mean moving off of more dangerous ground, such as with roots or stones. Safety trumps immersion. Immersion trumps your convenience, though.) Generally, you'll want to purchase something that might run a little pricier because it'll be better for you in the long run. It's not guaranteed, but with LARP gear it usually follows that the more it costs the better it is.
Matt's right about damage from being put in a belt, by the way, but there's another reason not to do that. If you have to draw your sword, then your belt suddenly has a lot of slack in it. If you have two swords, that's even more slack. That'll throw you off in a fight something fierce.
Incidentally, feel free to find me at a game for florentine lessons, and I don't mean the skill on your sheet. I'm one of the better florentine fighters, which is ironic since I can't get the skill on my main character! Look for a grumpy Russian healer with a beard and a real wooden staff, dressed in earth tones; or a cheerful swashbuckler in black and red, large black leather hat with peacock feathers, same beard (obviously), and a Spanish accent; or a seemingly-humorless bearded Londwynian physician with a vintage doctor's bag. I may or may not be in the company of barbarians no matter the character I'm wearing, and I can frequently be found by poking one's head into the kitchen on Saturdays.
I find the best way is to have two swords on opposite hips from the hands that will be holding them. Back sheaths look cool but are impractical both coming and going. Same-side sheathes tend to only work when you have a much shorter secondary weapon. (Remember, unlike in real life, you do have to be concerned about latex and foam catching on the sides of the frog. Steel is a different matter.)
Another thing to be concerned about is that the combination of length of blade and angle of frog might cause inconvenience. I have three types of frogs (other than the mug frog, which is only used for a mug). One is a high, fixed frog which keeps my sword off the ground but doesn't allow much flexibility when sitting. The second is lower and more flexible, but if I'm not careful can let the tip of my sword drag on the ground; I've even (once) managed to trip on my own sword because it swung between my legs while I was walking fast. Both of these are angled at about 40 degrees or so. The third frog is straight up and down, and typically gives me the least problems, but I also use that frog to carry my offhand weapon; while it's a 1HE, it's shorter and skinnier.
When shopping for frogs, keep in mind that you'll want to be able to draw in a hurry; sometimes fights get sprung on you completely out of the blue, and it's not fair to the NPCs (not to mention immersion-breaking) to ask them to wait while you get situated for anything less than a safety concern, even if they want to. (And they aren't required to, again excepting safety. Safety means something like "I'm carrying this heavy/breakable object. Please hold a moment while I move it off to the side, then return to my spot where you can proceed to kill me." I did that with a drink this last event. It can also mean moving off of more dangerous ground, such as with roots or stones. Safety trumps immersion. Immersion trumps your convenience, though.) Generally, you'll want to purchase something that might run a little pricier because it'll be better for you in the long run. It's not guaranteed, but with LARP gear it usually follows that the more it costs the better it is.
Matt's right about damage from being put in a belt, by the way, but there's another reason not to do that. If you have to draw your sword, then your belt suddenly has a lot of slack in it. If you have two swords, that's even more slack. That'll throw you off in a fight something fierce.
Incidentally, feel free to find me at a game for florentine lessons, and I don't mean the skill on your sheet. I'm one of the better florentine fighters, which is ironic since I can't get the skill on my main character! Look for a grumpy Russian healer with a beard and a real wooden staff, dressed in earth tones; or a cheerful swashbuckler in black and red, large black leather hat with peacock feathers, same beard (obviously), and a Spanish accent; or a seemingly-humorless bearded Londwynian physician with a vintage doctor's bag. I may or may not be in the company of barbarians no matter the character I'm wearing, and I can frequently be found by poking one's head into the kitchen on Saturdays.
Main: Grigori the grumpy healer, adopted member of the Tribe of Berk, adviser to Chief Darius Redmaw.
Alt: Dorian White, physician and alchemist for hire.
Alt: Ruy Sanchez de Castor y Ortiz, the best swordsman in all of Coast Haven!
OOC: Matthew Bowman
Science fiction and fantasy editor, longtime tabletop GM, newbie KR player.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis)
- Andrew Greyscar

- New Member

- G'day Mates
- Posts: 8
- Thank Yous: 6
8 years 2 months ago - 8 years 2 months ago #151051
by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis)
Andrew Greyscar (Master Florentine Swashbuckler)
Oliver Greenbottle (Alchemist)
OOG: Michael Tollis
Replied by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis) on topic Carrying Weapons
@ Grumpy: Did you happen to get potato soup from someone cooking in a dutch oven in the October event? If so I think I know who you are.
Also I may take you up on the florentine fighting lessons. I actually do have some sparring experience from taking karate for several years, but not much in the way of weapons or LARP fighting.
Also I may take you up on the florentine fighting lessons. I actually do have some sparring experience from taking karate for several years, but not much in the way of weapons or LARP fighting.
Andrew Greyscar (Master Florentine Swashbuckler)
Oliver Greenbottle (Alchemist)
OOG: Michael Tollis
Last edit: 8 years 2 months ago by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis).
The following user(s) said Thank You: Mantel (sigma-j)
- Grumpy

- Junior Member

- May be appeased with kittens.
- Posts: 90
- Thank Yous: 64
8 years 2 months ago #151070
by Grumpy (Bookwyrm)
Main: Grigori the grumpy healer, adopted member of the Tribe of Berk, adviser to Chief Darius Redmaw.
Alt: Dorian White, physician and alchemist for hire.
Alt: Ruy Sanchez de Castor y Ortiz, the best swordsman in all of Coast Haven!
OOC: Matthew Bowman
Science fiction and fantasy editor, longtime tabletop GM, newbie KR player.
Replied by Grumpy (Bookwyrm) on topic Carrying Weapons
I did not get any potato soup, so I'm afraid I'm still a mystery.
If you've taken several years of karate, that will make it easier. My base footwork is about 80% karate when it comes to florentine, 10% eskrima, and 10% actual Italian Florentine. And as you no doubt know, footwork is more than half your combat.
You may still need to break a couple habits if you were trained for tournament style (which almost everyone who takes American karate learns), but it's not much. I was trained at a dojo that did both tournament and street fighting, and (despite my sensei asking repeatedly) never did tournaments. I was there to learn to spar. Which is also why I will never play a monk, because close fighting instincts tend to take over even with brawlers.
When we get closer to the event, I'll let you know what my schedule is looking like. Odds are I'll be on my healer for the first three periods, and then my swashbuckler on Sunday.
If you've taken several years of karate, that will make it easier. My base footwork is about 80% karate when it comes to florentine, 10% eskrima, and 10% actual Italian Florentine. And as you no doubt know, footwork is more than half your combat.
You may still need to break a couple habits if you were trained for tournament style (which almost everyone who takes American karate learns), but it's not much. I was trained at a dojo that did both tournament and street fighting, and (despite my sensei asking repeatedly) never did tournaments. I was there to learn to spar. Which is also why I will never play a monk, because close fighting instincts tend to take over even with brawlers.
When we get closer to the event, I'll let you know what my schedule is looking like. Odds are I'll be on my healer for the first three periods, and then my swashbuckler on Sunday.
Main: Grigori the grumpy healer, adopted member of the Tribe of Berk, adviser to Chief Darius Redmaw.
Alt: Dorian White, physician and alchemist for hire.
Alt: Ruy Sanchez de Castor y Ortiz, the best swordsman in all of Coast Haven!
OOC: Matthew Bowman
Science fiction and fantasy editor, longtime tabletop GM, newbie KR player.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Nalick (NalickDeMarche), Mantel (sigma-j)
- Andrew Greyscar

- New Member

- G'day Mates
- Posts: 8
- Thank Yous: 6
8 years 2 months ago - 8 years 2 months ago #151080
by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis)
Andrew Greyscar (Master Florentine Swashbuckler)
Oliver Greenbottle (Alchemist)
OOG: Michael Tollis
Replied by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis) on topic Carrying Weapons
I will likely not attend again until the spring. I have a long trip from home, and the 5 hour drive plus admission cost doesn't feel worth it in the cold weather as non-combat. I still would likely need to be non-combat for a month or 2 anyway because I broke my wrist in September and the cast will be removed only a few days before the December event. I should be able to do combat when I return in the spring.
Andrew Greyscar (Master Florentine Swashbuckler)
Oliver Greenbottle (Alchemist)
OOG: Michael Tollis
Last edit: 8 years 2 months ago by Andrew Greyscar (Mtollis).
The following user(s) said Thank You: Mantel (sigma-j)
Moderators: Lois Heimdell (LoisMaxwell)
Time to create page: 0.475 seconds
Random Quote
"You have many attributes that fit well with my order, except for you know, that whole you being a blasphemous nonbeliever bit."
~Sir Nigel Stormbringer, Paladin, to Sir Alexander Renaudierre
