Long sword VS Katana

16 years 1 month ago #37640 by Jurgur'mosh Goretusk (MattF)



Overall i believe the Katana would Win.

Jurgur'mosh GoreTusk
free orc
(OOG-Matt F)
  • Thorgrim Ironfeld
  • Thorgrim Ironfeld's Avatar
  • Premium Member
  • Premium Member
  • Half of an analysis....is anal.
  • Posts: 331
  • Thank Yous: 0
16 years 1 month ago #37644 by Thorgrim Ironfeld (MitchC)
Oh no, this debate again. Katana is far better slashing, the Albion, broad sword or any of those swords from that region were a  much better cutter/stabber, infact most European LS's are. Different weapons with different strengths. I need to dig up one of the best studies (video and pics) I ever saw that shows the inherent differences with real cutting  and penetration power, etc. It will change your perspective and open your mind :)

FYI, those were 2 handed rattan, just to nitpick, heh. Try this one (
) I've a much better one, but its dug deep in my files. That one shows vs various armor types of the day.

OOG name: Mitch
Master Runesmith of Pendarvin

Don't let the grey hair fool you...wait scratch that...DO let the grey hair fool you.
_____
I make leather armor and various items for sca, larps and dagorhir. Here's my photobucket: s297.photobucket.com/albums/mm233/mc1csmo/
  • Radu Dragovic
  • Radu Dragovic's Avatar
  • Premium Member
  • Premium Member
  • -Death is but a Door-
  • Posts: 365
  • Thank Yous: 1
16 years 1 month ago #37646 by Radu Dragovic (Radu Dragovic)
Sometimes, its not just the weapons.

Its the skill, moral, strength, tactics, and the weather even.

The spirit of the warrior by many traditions varies but in linked by the strength of will. Warriors vary in martial teachings and skill. So luck plays in sometimes too. LOL.

There are never any absolutes in combats, save for one will die and one will live......maybe.



Radu Dragovic-Guild Grave Digger and Carpenter of The Black Orchid Merchant Company



-Death is but a doorway, we are richer to of know you and luckier still to have called you friend-

OOG: Jeff Mclean
The following user(s) said Thank You: Rowan Uidhir (Teresa)
16 years 1 month ago #37648 by Ded Dawg O'Doul (Mohammad)


Another offering about Katana VS  ??

Any one watch the  cable TV "Deadliest Warrior ?" Many comparisons about fighters ,weapons, techniques

We hold in our hands the harvest of what we have sown in Hope. Do we sow for Good? or for Evil?

Ded Dawg O'Doul

OOG = Dave Sullivan Sr; Indiana

Kanarak=VC999 Institutional Head
PC = Ded Dawg O'Doul. Inn Keeper
NPC = Huh! The Dumbest of the Ale Belly Ogres
16 years 1 month ago #37649 by Ded Dawg O'Doul (Mohammad)

We hold in our hands the harvest of what we have sown in Hope. Do we sow for Good? or for Evil?

Ded Dawg O'Doul

OOG = Dave Sullivan Sr; Indiana

Kanarak=VC999 Institutional Head
PC = Ded Dawg O'Doul. Inn Keeper
NPC = Huh! The Dumbest of the Ale Belly Ogres
16 years 1 month ago #37650 by Jurgur'mosh Goretusk (MattF)
That show was very controversial, I more or less agree with Jeff's philosophy, Its not the tools, its the handyman.

Jurgur'mosh GoreTusk
free orc
(OOG-Matt F)
Time to create page: 0.490 seconds