Has anyone seen the "Sword of Truth" tv series

17 years 2 months ago #17184 by Mother Rosa (Kate)
I admit some things don't translate well onto screen. With these books however, it seems even the things that would have translated well and were perfectly described in the books (I'm looking at you Confessor power) were done in a horribly cheesy way off manner. I can think of few things besides epic amounts of traveling that wouldn't have gone over well for the most part with only minor tweaks. And the traveling easily could have happened between episodes.

Mother Rosa
Priestess of Gaia

"That which yields is not always weak."


((oog: Kate L))
  • geezer
  • geezer's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 4349
  • Thank Yous: 448
17 years 2 months ago #17185 by geezer (geezer)
Actually, Joe, I loved the Princess Bride book.  Movie was great as well - one of the few times both were hits with me.  Sometimes (In the Heat of the Night comes to mind) the movie is better, but mostly it is the book.  The Trouble with Tribbles Star Trek episode was very good for 48 minutes, but compared to the Heinlein book The Rolling Stones from which Gerold stole the idea, there is no comparison.

I was kinda proud of the reference.  It fit on so many levels.  I'm impressed with your knowledge of the classics. :)

Edwin Haroldson
Loremaster
Master of the Mages' Guild

An ethical person does the right thing when no one is watching.

OOG - Charlie Spiegel - Kitchen Marshal

"War is a matter of vital importance to the State..."
  • JoDios
  • JoDios's Avatar
  • Elite Member
  • Elite Member
  • That guy with the muffin hat.
  • Posts: 717
  • Thank Yous: 0
17 years 2 months ago #17186 by JoDios (JoDios)
The book is often better but I didn't find that the case with the Princess Bride.  After the 3rd or 4th time of the author going off on a tangent about some "historical fact" about the two kingdoms and then didn't get back to the story, I started to get annoyed and skipped them whenever it went into a rant so I could learn what was happening to the main characters.


OOG: Jo
  • geezer
  • geezer's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 4349
  • Thank Yous: 448
17 years 2 months ago #17187 by geezer (geezer)
But the admitedly great scene when Montoya and Wesley are fencing took nine pages in the book and was sooo great.  I admit I also skipped some of the crapola.

Edwin Haroldson
Loremaster
Master of the Mages' Guild

An ethical person does the right thing when no one is watching.

OOG - Charlie Spiegel - Kitchen Marshal

"War is a matter of vital importance to the State..."
  • Kendrick
  • Kendrick's Avatar
  • Premium Member
  • Premium Member
  • Posts: 377
  • Thank Yous: 4
17 years 2 months ago #17191 by Kendrick (Kendrick)
All of this filler talk makes me think one chapter that never needed to be written ' The House of Tom Bombadil'

Brother Kendrick Maeldun
Paladin of the White Fox

oog Chris K
  • dedrite
  • dedrite's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • For the Emperor!
  • Posts: 598
  • Thank Yous: 1
17 years 2 months ago #17197 by dedrite (dedrite)

All of this filler talk makes me think one chapter that never needed to be written ' The House of Tom Bombadil'


THANK YOU!

-Brother Knight Templar Sabatheous Tellinghast-
Knight Templar of the Order of the Brilliant Hammer
Holy Inquisitor of the Church of Kormyre



Crudelius est quam mori semper timere mortem

"Nothing is ever forgotten"

((Joe Bondi-Marketing Officer))
Time to create page: 0.456 seconds