I do believe an honor challenge was made, and acknowledged. Anyone else not designated as a second by either party has no further business in this line of discussion, I think. Leave this matter of honor between the two knights.
Templar Aldric
Champion Fisherman of Amanthyre
Prophet of the Holy Light
Templar of Valos
image missing http://www.knightrealms.com/images/sigils/Kormyre-Church-Small.png
"The sacred writings are quite specific on the subject of killing, but are a bit fuzzier on the topic of kneecaps."
OOG - David McCormick.