- Posts: 188
- Thank you received: 1
Shields for Sale
- Father Paul
-
Topic Author
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
- Kitchen Marshals
18 years 6 months ago #2136
by Father Paul
Priest of Gaia
The Eyes in the Sky
oog Paul W.
Replied by Father Paul on topic Shield & Headbands for Sale
I will not be at this upcoming event, But you will have them by the next event if not sooner.
Priest of Gaia
The Eyes in the Sky
oog Paul W.
- Visitor
-
18 years 5 months ago #3903
by Ardin
Lord Ardin Silverbow
Lord of Pendarvin
"While others succumb, we overcome."
-Silverbow Motto
OOG: Norm B
Safety Deputy
"When I think of the greatness of my job and realize that I am what I am, I am amazed, but on reflection, who is as good as I am? I know of no one."
-George Patton(I wish Ardin had said this first)
Replied by Ardin on topic Shield & Headbands for Sale
Is that $20 or 50 gold?
Norm B
Norm B
Lord Ardin Silverbow
Lord of Pendarvin
"While others succumb, we overcome."
-Silverbow Motto
OOG: Norm B
Safety Deputy
"When I think of the greatness of my job and realize that I am what I am, I am amazed, but on reflection, who is as good as I am? I know of no one."
-George Patton(I wish Ardin had said this first)
- GJSchaller
-
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
- Character is to a person, what carbon is to steel.
18 years 5 months ago #3929
by GJSchaller
Replied by GJSchaller on topic Shield & Headbands for Sale
OOG sales need to be in OOG money. IG sales need to be in IG money.
Unfortunately, it is metagaming to sell an OOG shield to someone for IG coin only.
Unfortunately, it is metagaming to sell an OOG shield to someone for IG coin only.
| 
Lord Gideon Weaveforger of Kaladonia Steward of Elvalion OOG: Geoffrey Schaller |
- GJSchaller
-
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
- Character is to a person, what carbon is to steel.
18 years 5 months ago #3953
by GJSchaller
Replied by GJSchaller on topic Shield & Headbands for Sale
That still is not allowed - you are selling an Out-Of-Game physrep for IG coin, which is the issue.
This same ruling is why Charlie could not sell OOG latex weapons, or books, for gold IG.
Minor items that are IG, like food, is usually acceptable because it promotes atmosphere (such as someone with Trade: Cook selling food), but anything of a more substantial value, such as a latex sword, shield, or other prop, causes a problem in that you are basically buying IG coin with OOG resources, and no skill on your PC's card to justify it. (Even as a Blacksmith, it would be questionable, due to the value of the items.)
One should be paying gold for an Item or Commodity Card, and not the OOG prop. One should be paying OOG money for a Prop, and not for item cards or other IG benefits.
This same ruling is why Charlie could not sell OOG latex weapons, or books, for gold IG.
Minor items that are IG, like food, is usually acceptable because it promotes atmosphere (such as someone with Trade: Cook selling food), but anything of a more substantial value, such as a latex sword, shield, or other prop, causes a problem in that you are basically buying IG coin with OOG resources, and no skill on your PC's card to justify it. (Even as a Blacksmith, it would be questionable, due to the value of the items.)
One should be paying gold for an Item or Commodity Card, and not the OOG prop. One should be paying OOG money for a Prop, and not for item cards or other IG benefits.
|
|
Lord Gideon Weaveforger of Kaladonia Steward of Elvalion OOG: Geoffrey Schaller |
Moderators: LoisMaxwell
Time to create page: 0.477 seconds