Alchemists of Travance.

Sounds early. Can we make it closer to 11 bells?

-N. Flamel

As we grow closer to coming feast I feel like I have neglected to set anything down! My apologies everyone! So yes, 11 bells in the morning is our meeting time. I figured at the in at the big table would be the best place for us? Furthermore I will set in the topics of discussion so far we have two.

1. Should the alchemists become a guild?

2. Do we consider the homunculi alive?

On top of that, I do not wish for this to become a crowd of emotion. This is a scientific debate, present evidence to your belief, but do not insult anyone. This I assume will be the conversation that has us decide all together in the future of how we treat these creations in the future.

I will add one more thing to this. I am willing to do it, but I'd prefer to name a speaker who will control the flow of the conversation and make sure everyone has their turn to speak.

Signed,
Dunn Ironwil

I don't think anyone is going to argue that the homunculi are by all definitions "alive" - same as a tree or a possum. Isn't the more important question regarding their personhood? If they are to be qualified among humans, elves, fae-kin, and goblinoids as "people"?

The four True Homunculi were willing to give their lives to defend me. They show compassion and a desire for understanding that grows every day. Though they may be called childlike, or do not behave in a way that you are necessarily used to, that is far more than I can say for some humans, elves, faerie kin, and goblinoids.