Rules Update: Master Warrior
- Alexandre Blythewood

- Platinum Member

- Posts: 2122
- Thank Yous: 284
14 years 1 month ago - 14 years 1 month ago #65126
by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix)
-Alexandre Blythewood
OOG: Zach Theis
Replied by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix) on topic Rules Update: Master Warrior
I noticed a few traits missing from some of the skills. Were any of the following intentional?
1) The description of Devastating Blow states that the attack is piercing, but it lacks the Piercing trait.
2) Slay lacks the Lethal trait.
3) Slam doesn't have Condition (Knocked Prone)
4) Both Master Proficiency and Defensive Fighting seems to fit the description of the Proficiency trait.
5) Perfect Strike can be used with defensive or offensive skills, but it lacks the Defense trait.
Also, a trait related question: Why is Bypass Armor a Social skill. If that's not a mistake, can defenses that stop other social skills (I'm specifically thinking of Willpower) prevent a Bypass Armor?
1) The description of Devastating Blow states that the attack is piercing, but it lacks the Piercing trait.
2) Slay lacks the Lethal trait.
3) Slam doesn't have Condition (Knocked Prone)
4) Both Master Proficiency and Defensive Fighting seems to fit the description of the Proficiency trait.
5) Perfect Strike can be used with defensive or offensive skills, but it lacks the Defense trait.
Also, a trait related question: Why is Bypass Armor a Social skill. If that's not a mistake, can defenses that stop other social skills (I'm specifically thinking of Willpower) prevent a Bypass Armor?
-Alexandre Blythewood
OOG: Zach Theis
Last edit: 14 years 1 month ago by Unnamed user.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Erdrick

- Platinum Member

- Posts: 2147
- Thank Yous: 161
14 years 1 month ago #65127
by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Master Warrior
A bunch of those will be fixed in the updated edition with more cleaned up descriptions. What I will say though is that Devastating strike is not piercing, but an original incarnation was. The new description will reflect that when its done.
Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Erdrick

- Platinum Member

- Posts: 2147
- Thank Yous: 161
14 years 1 month ago #65128
by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Master Warrior
Also that being said don't stop posting oddities like that. It'll help us clean things up as we make the more complete version.
Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Alexandre Blythewood

- Platinum Member

- Posts: 2122
- Thank Yous: 284
14 years 1 month ago - 14 years 1 month ago #65129
by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix)
-Alexandre Blythewood
OOG: Zach Theis
Replied by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix) on topic Rules Update: Master Warrior
A couple random questions:
1a) Does Rend Limb actually have a mechanical pain effect involved, or is it just a roleplay effect? If there is a mechanic involved, can Ignore Pain defend against that part of the skill?
1b) Same as above, except for Sever Limb.
2) Can I use Perfect Balance in response to Throw, avoiding the 10 foot movement and instead just falling prone?
3) Can Perfect Balance defend against Dust Devil?
1a) Does Rend Limb actually have a mechanical pain effect involved, or is it just a roleplay effect? If there is a mechanic involved, can Ignore Pain defend against that part of the skill?
1b) Same as above, except for Sever Limb.
2) Can I use Perfect Balance in response to Throw, avoiding the 10 foot movement and instead just falling prone?
3) Can Perfect Balance defend against Dust Devil?
-Alexandre Blythewood
OOG: Zach Theis
Last edit: 14 years 1 month ago by Unnamed user.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Erdrick

- Platinum Member

- Posts: 2147
- Thank Yous: 161
14 years 1 month ago #65130
by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Master Warrior
1a+b) Roleplay effect.
2) As awkward as it sounds based off the current wording you would just be knocked prone. Though I might petition to have that changed as it seems kind of weird.
3) Yes but its a similar situation as with Throw.
2) As awkward as it sounds based off the current wording you would just be knocked prone. Though I might petition to have that changed as it seems kind of weird.
3) Yes but its a similar situation as with Throw.
Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Rannick

- New Member

- By the Sword - Live and Die
- Posts: 39
- Thank Yous: 0
14 years 1 month ago #65137
by Rannick (Rannick)
--R--
--Andy--
Those who draw a line between the soldier and the scholar will have their thinking done by cowards and their fighting done by fools.
Replied by Rannick (Rannick) on topic Rules Update: Master Warrior
This might have already been addressed, but this thread has gotten huge:
From "Perfect Strike:"
"The character must be within her weapon’s reach of the intended target to use this skill. If coupled with a Parry or Deflect those defenses become Superior."
This wording is very confusing. What does it mean? Does it mean you could use Perfect Strike with Parry or Deflect in order to make said Parry or Deflect Superior?
If so, does that mean you could use Perfect Strike with other defenses?
From "Perfect Strike:"
"The character must be within her weapon’s reach of the intended target to use this skill. If coupled with a Parry or Deflect those defenses become Superior."
This wording is very confusing. What does it mean? Does it mean you could use Perfect Strike with Parry or Deflect in order to make said Parry or Deflect Superior?
If so, does that mean you could use Perfect Strike with other defenses?
--R--
--Andy--
Those who draw a line between the soldier and the scholar will have their thinking done by cowards and their fighting done by fools.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Moderators: Lois Heimdell (LoisMaxwell)
Time to create page: 0.508 seconds
Random Quote
"Never fear death... fear a wasted life."
~Morwenne Darkstar
